Contenders

 

The reasons for the intensity and persistence of Blaine’s appeal seem elusive in some respects today. See the related Q&A.  The senator from Maine and former Speaker of the House was clearly an intelligent, savvy and highly skilled politician, but his career was also haunted by scandals. Most notably, Blaine was implicated, but cleared, in the Credit Mobilier bribery scandal.


: James G. Blaine was a formidable contender for the 1880 Republican presidential nomination.

Blaine supported the Fourteenth Amendment, which advanced the political rights of black Americans, and supported measures stipulating that any military governments set up in Southern states first have a plan on when and how to transition to civilian governments. This stance highlights Blaine’s credentials as a key member of the moderate, so-called “Half-Breed” faction of the Republican Party. The Republicans who supported Grant, known as the Stalwarts, favored stronger measures than did the Half-Breeds to enforce civil rights legislation in the South. Half-Breeds, whose ranks also included President Hayes, Rep. James A. Garfield, and Secretary of the Treasury John Sherman, also favored some civil service reform, although some have seen this stance more as a competition with the Stalwarts over patronage jobs than as reform.

On another political front, Blaine pushed for measures to prohibit public funds from being spent for parochial schools. These so-called Blaine Amendments have been described ever since as either a progressive separation of church and state or as a politically expedient, anti-Catholic measure. Blaine also supported a ban on Chinese immigration, a hot-button issue in 1880 in California, whose 12-member delegation, incidentally, voted unanimously for Blaine on the first ballot at the Chicago convention that year.

Sherman was another serious contender who would garner 93 votes on the first ballot in Chicago. Others with considerable support were Senator George F. Edmunds of Vermont and Elihu Washburne, a Grant ally now seen as a viable compromise candidate.

 

<< Grant and the Campaign for a Third Term >>
A Boom For Grant Contenders Other Hurdles
Grant's Participation The Big Three Battlegrounds Tactics
The National Convention A Third Term for Grant: Point - Counterpoint
The 1880 Republican National Convention in Chicago: The Setting
Conkling Nominates Grant Was Grant a Candidate? Q&A with author Ken Ackerman
Sources

Home